Lupactnessshouldprovablybeanultipact.ThebasicproblepactinN.
Ofcourse,theshapeoftheanswerdependsonwhatwepactnessofδinNshould“directlytraceback”toitssupercopleteandforallF:P_δ(λ)oλ,ifFisregressiveU-ae(i.e.,if\{a\pactiffforallλthereisanorpactiffforallλthereisanelepactnesswasfoundbyMagidor,anditwillplayakeyroleintheselectinthisreforpactness,althoughrecentresultssuggestthatthisis,infact,aredherring.
Thekeynotionwewillbestudyingisthefollowing:
Definition.N\subseteqVisaweakextenderpact’iffforallλ&apactnessofδinNdirectlywithitssupercopact’isdenotedbyo^N_{pact.
Solovay’sLepleteultrafilter{\mathcalV}onλ.Thedefinabilityinfactensuresthat{\mathcalV}\inV^λ/{\mathcalV},contradiction.Wewillencounterasimilardefinablesplittingargumentinthethirdlecture.
LetXconsistofthosea\inP_δ(λ)suchthat,letting\beta=\sup(a),wehave{mcf}(\beta)>\omega,and
a=\{\alpha<\beta\midS_\alpha\cap\betaisstationaryin\beta\}.
Thenfis1-1onXsince,bydefinition,anya\inXcanbereconstructedfrom\vecSand\sup(a).AllthatneedsarguingisthatX\inUforanynormalfinemeasureUonP_δ(λ).(ThisshowsthattodefineU-measure1sets,weonlyneedapartition\vecSofS^λ_\omegaintostationarysets.)
Letj:VoMbetheultrapowerembeddinggeneratedbyU,so
U=\{A\inP_δ(λ)\midj‘λ\inj(A)\}.
Weneedtoverifythatj‘λ\inj(X).First,notethatj‘λ\inM.Lettingau=\sup(j‘λ),wethenhavethatM\models{mcf}(au)=λ.Since
M\modelsj(λ)\geauisregular,
itfollowsthatau<j(λ).Let\left<T_\beta\mid\beta<j(λ)ight>=j(\left<S_\alpha\mid\alpha<λight>).InM,theT_\betapartitionS^{j(λ)}_\omegaintostationarysets.Let
A=\{\beta